1917.02.20: NEW YORK POOR RIOT FOR FOOD


February 20, 1917

NEW YORK POOR RIOT FOR FOOD

MOB OF WOMEN STORMS OFFICE OF CITY MAYOR CRYING "WE WANT BREAD"

PEDDLERS MOBBED WHEN PRICES RISE PAST SLIM PURSES

Push-Cart Merchant Are Attacked in Wild Riots in New York Slum Districts

Police Guard thrown Around Office of Mayor to Fend Off Protesting Crowd

PINCHED BABES IN ARMS MOTHERS FOR MOB

Dealers Charge That Higher-ups Are Boosting Prices


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
12 Cents Before the War as Good as Dollar Now

NEW YORK, Feb. 20.—A dollar in New York today will only purchase the food that 12 cents would before the outbreak of the European war in 1914. These figures were announced by John J. Hartigan Commissioner of weights and measures, after an exhaustive investigation into the city’s food supply and market. [$0.12 in 1914 equals around $2.80 in 2013; $1.00 in 1917 equals around $18.20 in 2013]
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
NEW YORK, Feb. 20—Crying “we want bread, we want bread” more than 300 women, bare-headed, scantily clad—their warmest garment being a shawl thrown about their shoulders—stormed up the steps of the city hall here Tuesday, demanding relief from mayor Mitchel from the high cost of food.

Some have declared their families were starving.

Most of the women carried babies, their faces showing the pinch of hunger in their arms.

The women were headed by Mrs. Ida Harris, president of the Mothers' Vigilance league, and Marie Ganz, known as "Sweet Marie". They came from the Rutgers square tenement district where push cart peddlers have been steadily raising prices until the women declare they are now utterly unable to feed their families.

“We are starving, we want bread,” was the constant cry raised by the women as they surged about the entrance to the city hall.

At noon a delegation of women had gathered in front of police headquarters, demanding to see Police Commissioner Woods.

At the same time the police received word that two thousand additional women were forming in Rutgers square to march to the city hall.

A serious outbreak was threatened when Marie Ganz was arrested after the main body of women had been dispersed. The crowd in Rutgers square to march to the city hall.

A serious outbreak was threatened when Marie Ganz was arrested after the main body of women had been dispersed. The crowd in City hall park by this time numbered thousands. 

Women Rush Patrol 

“Sweet Marie” has been identified with agitators here and the police quickly sought to separate her from the women defanding [sic] food. She was hurried into the police precinct station in the city hall and then into a patrol wagon. Sighting her in the wagon, the women made a rush for it, yelling screaming and demanding her release. A line of police was quickly formed to stop the on-rushing women and the patrol whisked away.

Walking quietly across city hall park, the women were at the very steps of the building before they were noticed. They swept up the steps en masse. The doors were banged shut in their faces, and wild cries and imprecations followed. 

Police Drive Them Off 

A swarm of police reserves and Plain clothes men appeared. They drove the women down from the steps. Marie Ganz then mounted the…

(Continued on Page 6, Col. 4)
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

(Continued from Page 1)



PEDDLERS MOBBED WHEN PRICES RISE PAST SLIM PURSES 

…steps and addressed the women. She urged the women to remain in the street, and especially to do nothing that would give the police an excuse to arrest them. With this the crowd quieted and “Sweet Marie” and Mrs. Harris were admitted to the building as representatives of the protesting women.

Mrs. Harris declared she represented no political organization of any kind.

“I represent no one but mothers,” she said. “My husband is a watchmaker. I have three children and we just, manage to get alone. But other mothers who can't get along come to me with tears in their eyes and ask me what. To do.” 

Protest May Not Wait 

“We were promised a public school in which to hold a protest meeting next Tuesday. By that time, though, hundreds will be starving, so we determined to march down here to see him.”

Mrs. Harris was told that the mayor was not in his office, but was promised that he would meet them later. 

Riots in Tenement Districts 

There were riots Tuesday in three of New York's congested tenement Districts. Push carts were stripped, overturned and burned by frantic women.

In the Williamsburg section on Long Island, the open air market was wrecked and dealers hid behind barred and locked doors. Police reserves battled to restore order. The riot followed a sudden jump in the price of onions and potatoes.

In the Brownsville section and on the east side of Manhattan there were food riots almost as serious.
The trouble was started in Williamsburg when a woman, unable to pay the price demanded for onions put her shoulder to the push cart and tipped it over. In a moment hundreds of women were on their knees scrambling for the potatoes and onions. The confusion of the fight for food spread and soon other carts were in the street and the peddlers fleeing. Kerosene was thrown on some of the carts and some instances were set afire. 

Peddlers Deny Responsibility 

Later 2,000 residents of one district assembled in mass meeting to hear the peddlers’ side of the case. One man declared he made but twenty cents a barrel on potatoes that cost him $10. The dealers charged they were allowed to purchase at one time from only two cars of potatoes when eleven were on the tracks.

A boycott on onions or potatoes, in which dealers will agree not to purchase any more, seems probably. 

To Ask Other States’ Aid 

Commissioner of Weights and Measures Hartigan planned on Tuesday to send to state departments of food and markets, or other state officials throughout the union, a letter urging increased food shipments to this city.

Prices of foods, not only in the push cart, but in every section of the city, have advanced tremendously. The difference in the prices of some vegetables is shown in the following: 

[Note: 2013 prices is in red.]
String beans, 1917, 80 cents [$14.56] per pound; 1916, 20 to 40 cents [$4.29 to $8.58].
Lima beans, 1917, 40 cents [$7.28] per pound; 1916, 20 to 30 cents [$4.29 to $6.44].
Spinach, 1917, 25 cents [$4.55] per pound; 1916, 6 to 8 cents [$1.29 to $1.72].
White cabbage, 1917, 15 cents [$2.73] per pound; 1916 7 to 8 cents [$1.50 to $1.72].
Yellow squash, 1917, 10 cents [$1.82] each; 1916, 5 to 7 cents [$1.07 to $1.50].
Cauliflower, 1917, 25 cents [$4.55] each; 1916, 20 cents. [$4.29]
Potatoes, 1917, 10 cents [$1.82] per point; 1916, 4 cents. [$0.86]
Onions, 1917, 18 cents [$3.28] per pound; 1916, 9 cents. [$1.93] 

Police are Gentle 

For nearly an hour the confusion and near rioting continued in city hall park. Inspector Dyer was in charge of the police and went from patrolman to patrolman, cautioning them to “be easy, don’t push them, be careful.”

Tears streamed down the faces of scores of woman as they ran blindly from one line of police to the other, crying for bread.

A low hum that rose to a roar of women's shrieks and an atmosphere of waving fists and a sudden elevation of babies greeted her when Mrs. Harris tried to speak.

“We are starving!” the women shouted at her. “We want to see the mayor! We are American citizens and something must be done for us.”

It was with difficulty that Mrs. Harris made herself heard above the cries. Clenching her fists above her head, her eyes turned upward and glistening, she appealed for silence, “just for a moment.”

Police pleaded with the women, but they grew gradually more and more hysterical. A newspaperman volunteered his services and he mounted the steps.

“Go on home,” he told them in Yiddish, “The mayor has promised to see you tomorrow. He is for you. He wants to do all he can for the people.”

“Who are you?” they asked.

“Who do you represent?” 

Refuse to Disperse 

They cheered when he told them he was a reporter for a Jewish daily newspaper. But they didn’t disperse.

Around the circle of women and separate from them by a blue cordon of police a curious crowd of thousands hung on. Police lines were established and no one was allowed to pass.

As the gesticulating closely packed mob of women howled down the efforts of the Jewish newspaperman to quiet them, the riot squads under Inspector Dwyer edged in among the crowd and broke them up into groups.

Just as they were scattering out under the urging of the police they caught sight of Marie Ganz being loaded into a patrol wagon and the riot broke out afresh.

The forward groups, being urged over toward Park row, began to yell and make a dash across City hall place for the patrol wagon, while the other groups surged away from the city hall steps and hurried to join the chase. They took time as they ran to shake their fists and cry: “We want food! Give us milk! We’re starving!” 

Police Guard Patrol 

But the police lines straightened between the racing women and the black patrol wagon directly in front of Brooklyn bridge, and the rush degenerated into a free-for-all fight.

Meantime the patrol wagon whizzed away, the women yelling and shaking their fists after it and “Sweet Marie” Ganz waving a handkerchief and smiling.

After the brief skirmish in the park space between city hall, Park row and Brooklyn bridge, which followed this, with the general crowd breaking through the police lines and taking part, the women surged down Center street past the tombs and on toward police headquarters, with police, mounted and on foot, galloping along beside them. A crowd of thousands of men, women and children trailed excitedly in their wake.



http://newspaperarchive.com/la-crosse-tribune-and-leader-press/1917-02-20/page-6
 

1917.02.20: "SWEET MARIE'S" DEMAND ON BEHALF OF N.Y. POOR.

February 20, 1917

"SWEET MARIE'S" DEMAND ON BEHALF OF N.Y. POOR.


NEW YORK, Feb. 20.--"You can't expect us to keep quiet and starve to death" protested Marie Ganz leader of today's food riot when placed under arrest for disorderly conduct. "All we want is existence. We don't want to rob and plunder. But what are we going to do? It isn't natural for prices to jump like that, the mayor had ought to get the wholesalers together an look into the reasons for those prices."

Long known as a leader in social strife today marked the first public appearance of "Sweet Marie" Ganz in some time . It was this little woman who threatened the life of John D. Rockefeller, Jr., at the time of the Colorado coal strikes. She has served time at Blackwell's Island and has been prominent in many social demonstrations.



See also (words slightly different):




1917.02.20: Mob Of Starving Women Storms New York City Hall

Februrary 20, 1917

Mob Of Starving Women Storms New York City Hall

Feminine Horde From Tenement Houses And Ghetto Riot

Led By "Sweet Marie" Ganz They Terrify Financial District.

MAYOR MITCHEL NOT IN HIS OFFICE

Police Finally Scatter Crowd After Holding Leader on Riot Charge.

New York, Feb. 20.--Out of the Ghetto and the East Side tenements there swarmed hundreds of women screaming, "We are starved; we want bread."

They swooped down upon the City Hall where rioting and scenes of disorder followed.


Thousands of women of the telement [sic] district fell into the line, led by "Sweet Marie" Ganz. In a long line they came, old women, hobbling and stumbling, shawl-wrapped heads and young mothers, holding aloft pale and wan babies. Their screams rent the air as traffic officers attempted to break up the parade of protest.

Walls of Babes.

Their numbers had dwindled by the time they reached the City hall and began loud cries of hunger. Plaintive wails from crying babes and shrieks of enraged women--like an echo of the present revolutions of Europe--all added to the intense excitement. demands for Mayor Mitchel fail to bring out the chief executive, but instead there came mounted policeman.


Within a few minutes after the vanguard arrived and assaulted the doors of the City Hall more than 5,000 excited men and women filled City Hall Park and a second call for reserve police went in. Down Park row there came hundreds of eager spectators, lured on by the first riot scenes this city has seen for many a day. Business men from the financial districts and employes from offices and shops nearby all added to the throng which jammed in upon the City Hall. Then there came the long line of stragglers.

A line of police was formed about the City Hall and stormed by the screeching women, many of them holding babies aloft and crying out: "You see them--they are starving. We want bread!"

"Back to the Tenements."

Orders went out from police headquarters for the dispersal of the mob and traffic officers along the line of march drove the women still on the way back to the tenement houses.

Lieut. William Kennel, the Mayor's aide, finally appeared at the doors of the City Hall. The sight of uniformed aide was the signal for a new outbust [sic] from the mob. Finally it quieted sufficiently for Kennel to announce the mayor would receive a delegation of four of the women.

There were immediate cries of "Marie." "Marie." "Sweet Marie." A little woman made her way up the city hall steps and there were loud cheers for "Marie." "Sweet Marie." Marie Ganz was the first delegate to the mayor. She chose as her associates Mrs. Ida Harrison, president of the Mothers' Vigilance league of the Eastside; Mrs. Tillie J. Plosky and Mrs. Annie Walker, both leaders in the tenement districts.

Oure [sic] in the corridors of the city hall, the delegation found they had been deceived. Mayor Mitchel was not in his office and it was announced he might not be in all day.

Rushing out to the city hall steps Marie Ganz told the crowd they had been betrayed and haranguing her followers, she succeeded in starting anew the screeching and yelling. Suddenly she was seized from behind by  four husky policemen and dragged into the building where she was detained and then arrested for disorderly conduct.

Tumult Rises Again.

Robbed of their leader once more the roar of thousands of voices went up and little Benjamin Bernstein, 15, thin and scrawny, arose on the steps and addressed the crowd.

"I am starving." cried the lad, as tears swept down his pale face. "I've got a sister and a mother and a father and we all live on $3 a week. [$54.60 in 2013 dollars.]

Then the boy was swept into the maelstrom and his plaintive cries and protests were drowned by the moans and shrieks of the rioters as mounted police made their way through the mob attempting to break it up. After more than an hour of disorder, police finally succeeded in scattering the crowd in all directions and still shrieking out and muttering threats the hundreds of women made their way to the Ghetto and Eastside not in an organized body but in little groups, scattered by the police.

Today's demonstration was an aftermath of the food rioting yesterday in Hester and Rivington streets, and the Williamsburg and Brownsville districts. Incensed at the high prices charged by hucksters yesterday afteroon, hundreds of the tenement house women stormed push carts and street stands and wrecked them scattering the produce in the street.

Throngs of the frantic women assailed the police and attempted to rescue their leader, "Sweet Marie" Ganz when she was being taken from the city hall in a police patrol. Several times the women charged the officers and patrolmen were scratched during the melee. The women were finally driven off and "Marie" was taken to the Elizabeth street station.






See also:

Although the United States is not at war and England is, the price of potatoes is twice as high in this country as it is in Great Britain. A record of forty years standing was smashed today when potatoes went to 7 cents a pound [$1.27 in 2013 dollars] in New York. In London they are selling at three and a half cents a pound and by order of the government to more has been charged at this time...








1916.05.04: Edelson Leads Strike


May 4, 1916

I.W.W. Girl Leader Heads Needlework Strikers In New York

NEW YORK-—In retaliation for the locking out of 60,000 workers in the cloak and suit industry here, the allied unions have called a strike and between 40,000 and 60,000 workers have left their machines. The strikers are headed by Miss Becky Edelson, an I . W. W. girl agitator, who led the strikers in the May Day parade. Miss Edelson, has been active in former strikes in the needlework industries.






1916.05.16: Reds' Demonstration Fails.

May 16, 1916

Mayor Mitchel Guarded from "Reds"

Reds' Demonstration Fails.

Becky Edelson, Emma Goldman, et al, had planned another courier demonstration, but their plans when amiss.


1916.05.14: Mayor Mitchel Guarded from "Reds"' Edison Trudges with Flag

May 14, 1916

Mayor Mitchel Guarded from "Reds"' Edison Trudges with Flag

Preparedness Patriots March; 137,000 in Line


Reds Demonstration Failed

Becky Edelson, Emma Goldman, et al, had planned another counter demonstration, but their plans went amiss. The two, with a dozen other "reds," had stationed themselves in the building at 208 Fifth Avenue, on which they had fixed a "War Against War" banner.






1916.04.11: Free Speech Martyr Speaks For Peace

April 11, 1916


Free Speech Martyr Speaks For Peace

Becky Edelson of New York whose hunger strike for free speech made her famous, is now fighting for peace.

See also:




1916.03.02: Edelson in Philadelphia

March 2, 1916

WOMAN ANARCHIST TAKES STRONG GROUND AGAINST FORCE


Miss Rebecca Edelson Declares Her "Hunger Strike" Was a Physical Demonstration of the Value of Nonresistance


Edelson explains she is against force. Also discusses sex, women's role in life, and monogamy.

 Rebecca Edelson, the philosophical anarchist who transplanted the hunger strike to American soil and made effective use of it on Blackwell's Island in 1914, has come to Philadelphia to preach nonresistance as a substitute for force and militarism. Miss Edelson's creed is this:

Force is the greatest detriment to progress in the world. Coercion, both physical and mental, suppresses the development of the individual. Force has been carried to perfection in the international melee of militarism, the result of it stupendous slaughter of human beings.

"My hunger strike," said Miss Edelson, "was my first practical protest against force. I was arrested in New York because I preached a policy of nonintervention toward Mexico. I logically could not use force to fight force and therefore adopted the hunger strike as a means of passive resistance. It was successful."

It is difficult to make the general public realize that an anarchist does not believe in force and is generally opposed to it, added Miss Edelson.

"I stand irretrievably opposed to force--force on the part of nations as well as by individuals. Each nation at war honestly thinks itself the instrument to be used to crush force. And each nation has developed its own coercive cohorts of men and arms to preach the barbarism of force. They use force to down force. It makes a vicious circle," explained Miss Edelson.

Even though Miss Edelson is an enthusiastic industrialist, in fact, a leader of strikes, she objects to the use of force by the working people to obtain their ends.

"Firstly, the worker gains nothing by using force," she says. "No matter what degree of force he uses, whether it be sabotage or the methods of the MacNamaras, who were accused of employing dynamite in their fight, the worker will always be overcome. The odds are always against him. Nonresistance is the only means for him. He must lay down his tools. Let him ignore the Government, not oppose it. The world cannot exist without the worker."

But Miss Edelson is hopeful. She believes that the cult of force is giving way to one of humanitarianism. The present cry for militarism in America in only on the surface. A country no longer goes to war with an avowed statement of aggression. in the present war each country backed its call to the colors on the plea of defense against militarism.

Ideals will develop as militarism decreases. Freedom for nations from militaristic, forceful intentions, freedom for individuals from coercive social restrictions. Not even in the United States, the war shop of the Allies and the happy hunting ground for militaristic propaganda, does Becky, as she is known to radicals throughout the country, feel that militarism will flourish.

"I don't believe we are headed for preparedness. I am sure that if any  the effort were made today to force conscription on the workingman of America there would be the bitterest opposition. Twenty years from now, if the rapid propaganda continues, the germ of force may be instantaneous objection to compulsory military service."

Women after the war will begin to lead a normal sex life, Miss Edelson predicts. Each generation has its big group of reactionaries and a minute one of radicals. The radical of today is the reactionary of tomorrow. The war has hurried up the process, and women, who in Miss Edelson's opinion are not yet the mental equal of man, will develop to the same plane.

"To put it crudely, the female will develop into a woman. The added responsibility thrust on her in all the countries at war will force her to develop mentally and physical reaction will follow.

"Barrier's that have existed through the centuries will be broken down. The artificial form of life practiced by men and women today will disappear under the new regime. The reaction against artificial stimulation on the material life practiced today has endangered the progress of the human race.

"I believe that monogamy is the ideal solution for the man and woman problem. But I believe that the right companion is found only through experimentation. Won't the world ever realize that we radicals are the most moral people in the world?" was the last comment on present conditions made by Miss Edelson.

The problem of the ideals to be followed by America in contradiction to the militarism of the Eastern nations is the topic of Miss Edelson's lecture at Grand Hall, 410 Wharton street, tonight.





1915.06.09: Suffragist Silently Suffer Watching Men Get Vote Right


June 6, 1915

Suffragist Silently Suffer Watching Men Get Vote Right

College Women Wearing Caps and Gowns Make Voiceless Protest in Federal Court--Judge Doesn't See Why They Are So Anxious for Ballot.


It may seem remarkable to those familiar with the campaign of argument the suffragists have carried on, but Mrs. Charles L. Tiffany and her co-workers of the College Equal Suffrage League proved, in their visit to the Naturalization Court, that votes for women workers can present their case without speaking. Garbed in their caps and gowns, these native-born, college-bred women sat silent and attentive while thirty-six Germans, Austrians, Italians, Frenchmen, Scandinavians, Jews and Britons were made full citizens of this country with the right to participate in its government.

"Of course there will be no demonstration," Mrs. Tiffany said before entering the courtroom. "We come to protest by our presence against the exclusion of the 1,000,000 native-born women of this state from the franchise, and surely words are not needed."

The women came in automobiles, and changed from their street wraps to caps and gowns in the lower corridor of the Federal Building, with a crowd of the curious looking on. Then they made their way to the Naturalization Court, on the fifth floor, and from 10:30 o'clock until 12 sat in two rows in the rear seats. The doorman was struck with fright when he saw them approaching.

"Will they try to address the judge?" he inquired, and, though he was assured that they wouldn't, he kept an uneasy eye upon them until they left. 

Miss Becky Edelson, the girl leader of the I.W.W.'s was one of the spectators and sat near the college women.

"I read in the paper that they were going to do this, and I thought I'd like to see them," she said. "It's quite a novelty for me to come to court as a looker-on. I don't usually go to court unless I'm arrested.

"I think this stunt ought to have some effect. Anything that takes the starch out of the men is good. Some have to be convinced one way, some another. Some require bombs, some more quiet methods. I don't know that the vote is of such great value, but I think women ought to have it as well as the men."

Judge Augustus Noble Hand, who was presiding, didn't appear to be at all disconcerted by his voiceless visitors, but neither did their presence have any effect on his opinions about suffrage.

"I don't value my own vote enough to understand to understand why women should be so anxious for the ballot," he observed after court adjourned. "It seems to me that women are quite as well represented now as they would be if they had the franchise. I'd be quite willing to give up my vote if I could be represented by others, those of my class, understanding my needs. Of course," added Judge Hand, "if all the women want to vote they ought to have the right. But all of them don't."

However, the woman had some effect on at least one of the men who was naturalized. He was an Austrian, and at first he didn't understand what those black-gowned women were doing. When it was explained to him he nodded.

"Ya, ya," he said. "I vote now, I help the suffrages all I can."

The women represented various professions, including those of lawyer, doctor and writer. Several admitted that they were "just plain mothers." Among the thirty were Mrs. Charles Darnton (Wellesley), Miss Jessie Ashley (New York University), Miss Alice Morgan Wright (Smith), Mrs. Alice Baldridge (Wellesley), Mrs. Wendell Bush (Radcliffe), Miss Pauline Angell (Vassar), Mrs. William Spinney (Bryn Mawr), Dr. Elizabeth Balch Holmes (Bryn Mawr), Mrs. Edgerton Parsons (Smith), Mrs. Walter L. Harvey (Wellesley), Mrs. Frederick Pease (Bryn Mawr), Mrs. Francis Brewer (Vassar), Mrs. Frederick T. Ackerman (Bryn Mawr), Miss Margaret Calhoun (Vassar), Mrs. Clara Vail Brooks (Bryn Mawr), Miss Marian Bradley (Vassar), Mrs. Anne O'Hagan Shinn (Boston University), Miss Elinor Byrns (University of Chicago), and Mrs. Charles Tiffany (Bryn Mawr).

Dean Virginia Gildersleeve of Barnard promised to attend, but was unable at the last minute to do so.












1915.04.01: SPECTATORS IN COURTROOM FRIGHTENED BY EXPLOSIVE

April 1, 1915

SPECTATORS IN COURTROOM FRIGHTENED BY EXPLOSIVE

LAWYER WAVES BOTTLE OF COMPOSITION--DISARMED.

Thrill Is Furnished in Courtroom During Trial of Two Men at New York Charged With Planting Bombs.


New York, March 31. — The alleged written confession of Frank Abarno and Carmine Carbone, charged with making and placing a lighted bomb in St. Patricks Cathedral, March 2, were offered in evidence at their trial today, but ruled out by the court.

"William J. McCahill, the stenographer who took down the prisoners' statements, was permitted to testify as to what he heard the prisoners say. McCahill failed to remember the salient features of the alleged confessions, and Assistant District Attorney Train went on the stand himself.

Train admitted the prisoners had not been instructed as to their rights in giving information, but said this was unnecessary.

Mr. Train was permitted to say that in his presence Abarno stated Carbone made the bombs and that after they were made it was decided to destroy the cathedral as a protest against capitalism.

Did Not Want to Kill Anyone.

"After we walked into the cathedral I said to my companion we did not want to destroy human life and should leave the bombs unlighted, simply as a protest. When I had placed the bombs and began to walk out the detectives in the women's clothes grabbed us."

 Seventeen witnesses for the other side, including Sweet Marie Ganz, Louise Berger and other anarchist leaders, greeted Polignani with jeers and hisses when he walked from the courtroom, guarded by four detectives, at recess. There was mush hissing and some one spat in his face. Those who participated in the demonstration were hustled out of the building.

The afternoon session was taken up chiefly with the testimony of Captain of Detectives Thomas J. Tunney of the anarchist squad. He told of the arrests at the cathedral and corroborated the testimony of Detective Polignani, who associated with the defendants for weeks in order to learn their plans.

Had Plans All Arranged.

Captain Tunney testified that Abarno had confessed that he intended after the cathedral affair to follow the same course at the homes of Carnegie, Rockefeller and others. Similar action in the chief banks of the city was also a part of the plan of the men, he said, according to their statements.

There was a thrill in the courtroom late today while City Chemist David E. Relkey, who analyzed the explosives in the bombs, was on teh stand. He had testified that he found the composition in the bombs had as great an explosive power as gunpowder, when Lawyer Keir for the defense. In cross-examining the witness, held up a bottle containing a sample of the explosive, and waving it in the air, shouted:

"Isn't it a fact that you could drop a can of this stuff right here in the courtroom and it would not explode?"

Before the witness could answer court attendants sprang at the lawyer and snatched the bottle from his hands. The spectators settled back in their seats when the chemist said he did not think the composition would explode if suddenly dropped.



1915.04.01: NO DANGER IN BOMB, NEW DEFENSE PLEA

April 1, 1915

NO DANGER IN BOMB, NEW DEFENSE PLEA

Call Cathedral Officials to Prove Police Gave Assurances Against Damage.

COURT BARS FALSE WHISKER

Refuses to have Detective Make Up Before Jury--Prosecutor Train on Stand.


Subpoenas were issued yesterday for dignitaries of the Catholic Church to be witnesses for the defense of Carmine Carbone and Frank Abarno, the anarchists on trial before Judge Nott in General Sessions for trying to blow up St. Patrick's Cathedral on March 2.

Attorney Simon Pollock, for the defense, abandoned all effort to escape admission that a bomb was carried into the Cathedral and lighted there by one of the defendants. But he said the defense would show that the bomb was no more powerful than a big firecracker, that the police staged the whole affair as a bit of "play-acting," and that the Cathedral officials had been told that the bomb amounted to nothing, or they would not have allowed the Cathedral to be invade by a "horde of detectives bent on staging there the play of capturing a bomb maker."

During the testimony of Detective George D. Bernitz, who was in the Cathedral made up as an old man, Mr. Pollock tried to have Judge Nott order him to appear before the jury in the identical disguise he wore in the Cathedral. Mr. Pollock summoned the false hair, beard, and old-man clothes that helped Bernitz play his part, shook them at the jurors, and demanded that the detective put them on.

Maintains Court's Dignity.

There was a titter through the room and Judge Nott protested that such procedure would promote laughter and needlessly lower the dignity of the trial. he demanded to know why the lawyer insisted that Bernitz put on his disguise.

"Because, your Honor," said Mr. Pollock, "I want to show that this whole business was a bit of play acting in which the police, made up like vaudeville actors, had a full equipment of leading mean, stage hands, supes, and even an audience selected from among the Church officials who had been told that an anarchist was to be arrested in the cathedral.

Judge Nott decided that the defense could make its case clear enough by showing the disguise to the jurors.

The detective defended his disguise and its purpose. "Of course, I understand the sacredness of the Cathedral," he said in answer to a question, "and, as insinuated by the lawyer, I am not a Catholic. Yet I think that going to the cathedral disguised was part of the performance of a duty of great value to the people. Here was an anarchist with a bomb he wanted to light. If any able-bodied person should approach him his first act, naturally, would be one of concealment. But if an invalid--an old, limping man--should approach he would go right on with his work.

Saw Bomb Lighted.

"I approached in the only way I could to 'cover,' Abarno, and when he glanced at me and saw my feebleness and my gray hair he leaned over his bomb again and touched a lighted cigar to it. Then, of course, I caught him in my arms and tossed him to the detectives disguised as scrubwomen.

"I threw him into their arms because I had to take care of the lighted bomb. I picked up the bomb. I picked up the bomb, snuffed out the light and cut off a section of the fuse to keep in evidence."

From D.E. Roelkey, a Health Department chemist, the defense gained the admission that the mixture of antimony, sulphur, potash, and brown sugar in the bomb was one of the weakest of explosives. He testified to elaborate tests he made and said: "I found this explosive almost exactly equal in power to black powder."

Lawyer Pollock held up the bombs and asked the jurors to see that they were wrapped around them and an explosive inside that would not surpass in power an ordinary fire cracker. Mr. Pollock continued throughout the day to belittle the bombs and to try to prove that they would not have endangered anybody's life if they had exploded in the cathedral.

Train Takes Stand.

Assistant District Attorney Arthur Train, in charge of the prosecution, took the stand to tell about the bombs and the confessions made in his presence. He had not intended to be a witness, but he found that a police stenographer who took the interview could not read his notes with sufficient clearness to testify.

Mr. Train did not object to the effort of the defense to show that the bombs were not dangerous. He said Abarno tried to convert him to anarchism, and argued that he had no intention of harming any one, but did want to damage the cathedral as a protest against the service of the church to the rich.

Mr. Train got into the record the views expressed by Abarno to him, and also the contents of anarchistic documents, which, he said, had been well studied and absorbed by Abarno and Carbone before either of them met Detective Polignani.

From comments of Mr. Train both as a witness and as prosecutor it appeared that he meant to rest his case on the "state of mind" of the defendants as demonstrated by speeches they made, copies of which he was able to produce, and by literature which they handed to their friends with expressions of approval.

Mr. Pollock brought out in the cross examination of Mr. Train that there was no one within thirty feet of Abarno when he lighted the bomb, except detectives. Mr. Pollock held up before the jurors a bottle filled with powder that has been removed from Abarno's bomb.

Bomb Scare in Court.

 "You all know," he said, "that this would merely fizzle like a fizzling firecracker if I should light it. And you know that if I threw it on the floor it would not go off and would not harm any of you if it did."

He made a move as if to throw the bottle on the floor and two court attendants ran to rescue the bottle.

At the noon recess and again at the close of the afternoon session Detective Polignani was hissed by anarchist women in the corridor, among them "Sweet Marie" Ganz and Louise Berger, a half-sister of Carl Hanson, one of the men blown up with Arthur Caron while making a bomb last 4th of July.

The trial will be resumed at 10:30 o'clock today.






1915.03.03: I.W.W. AND REDS MORE DARING IN LAST 2 YEARS

March 3, 1915

I.W.W. AND REDS MORE DARING IN LAST 2 YEARS

Bombs Used Against Churches--Cathedral Damage by One.

ORATORS INCITED MEN TO VIOLENCE

Fiery Speeches Often Stopped--Many Demonstrations Aimed at the Rockefellers


The Industrial Workers of the World and various anarchistic groups in New York have been extremely active here within the last two years.

Raids upon restaurants, church, invasions and the exploding bombs—the latter costing at least four lives—have marked the trail of the Manhattan “Red.” Just what has occurred since January 1, 1914, follows:

1914.

February 27—Second Avenue Baptist Church invaded by I.W.W. Driven out by police reserves.

March 3—Frank Tannenbaum and 190 of his followers arrested in St. Alphonsus’s Roman Catholic Church, which they invaded, demanding food and shelter for the night. Taken to night court at a special sitting of the court arranged by Chief Magistrate McAdoo, Magistrate Campbell held Tannenbaum on $5,000 bail on charge of inciting a riot, and the rest of the mob were held for disorderly conduct.

Tannenbaum’s trial was held before Judge Wadhome. He was found guilty and sentenced to one year in the penitentiary and fined $300. Tannenbaum asked for immediate sentence after making inflammatory speech.

March 8—A ten inch stick of dynamite was found eight feet from St. Mark’s Church, Second Avenue and Tenth Street where I.W.W. had been given shelter a few nights before.

March 9—All Saints’ Church, Henry Street, invaded by two mobs of I.W.W. demanding food and beds for the night.

I.W.W. in Churches.

March 10—St. George’s Episcopal Church, of which the late J.P. Morgan was a member, and where his song worships, sheltered 100 I.W.W. “unemployed” in the Memorial Building, 209 East Sixteenth Street.

March 12—Riot in Cooper Union when I.W.W. attempted to break up Socialist meeting. Cry of “We want to eat. Quit talking and do something” brought the police and invaders were ousted.

March 28—Threats made against Madison Square Presbyterian Church. Thirty patrolmen detailed to watch edifice.

April 4—Two riots in Union Square. “Wild Joe” O’Carroll, Arthur Caron and six others arrested. Meeting called by the I.W.W. to discuss the question of unemployment.

April 9—Philip Novick set to work house for ten days for creating trouble during I.W.W. meeting. Of eight others arrested for were discharged; one put on probation for a year; one sent to workhouse for fifteen days and another for ten.

April 12—Jane Est, I.W.W. speaker, arrested while interrupting service in Madison square Presbyterian Church, of which Dr. Parkhurst is pastor. “This church has a minister who repudiates Christ!” she cried. “He said Christ had nothing to do with the conditions of the poor in New York.”

April 22—“Sweet Marie” Gans, I.W.W. agitator, arrested in front of Tribune office while making a speech in provoking an angry outburst from crowd. She was forced from the platform and finally rescued by police.

April 24—Becky Edelson found guilty of disorderly conduct and placed under bond of $300 to keep the peace, with Samuel Hartman, a fellow agitator. Sent to workhouse and immediately announced she would go on hunger strike.

April 25—“Wild Joe” O’Carroll, I.W.W. agitator and member of the Anti-Militarist League, in Union Square said: “if American workmen have to go to Mexico to shoot Mexican workmen, just make a mistake and turn the guns on your own officers. When you start killing them you will find that the war will stop soon enough.”

May 2—Marie Gantz arrested near 26 Broadway on a warrant charging her with uttering incendiary remarks against John D. Rockefeller, Jr. Denunciation of Rockefeller, general disorder in meetings held in the open marked one of the busiest May days known to New York police.

May 21—Mrs. J. Borden Harriman and members of the Industrial Relations Commission listened to Vincent St. John, six years secretary of the I.W.W., tell about sabotage.

No Respect for Property.

St. John said: “The I.W.W. does not advocate the destruction of human life to gain a certain point, but we are just coming to realize that the wealthy have been supporting themselves by draining the muscle and energy of the workers, without respect for their property, and we don’t intend to show any respect for the property of the wealthy if its disregard will aid us to gain our point.”

May 24—Alexander Berkman, Becky Edelson, Arthur Caron, and several hundred followers, in a riot in front of 74 East Fourth Street. Rocks thrown; police reserves called; two arrests made.

May 29—Judge Mulqueen sentenced David Shapiro, known to the I.W.W. as “Edward Gibbons,” to twenty years at hard labor in Sing Sing. Two accomplices were sent away, one for two years, the other for six months. The three assaulted and robbed Morris Sandler on April 18.

May 29—Becky Edelson, Arthur Caron, Edward Plunkett arrested in Tarrytown while attempting to hold a meeting and demonstration near Rockefeller estate.

May 30—Fifteen prisoners taken to Tarrytown jail; result of raid by town authorities upon I.W.W. and followers of Berkman.

June 1—Two followers of Berkman sentenced, one got three months and the other thirty days for causing trouble in Tarrytown near Rockefeller’s estate.

June 8-11—Tarrytown in turmoil, due to invasion of I.W.W., loudly armed men with automatic guns guard Pocantico Hills. Rifles stacked for workmen to use at given signal.

Driven from Tarrytown.

June 22—Alexander Berkman, Leonard D. Abbott and Arthur Caron, with Charles Plunkett, Becky Edelson, Helen Goldberg, Jennie Berger, Marie Yuster and Rose Yuster, leading a dozen sympathizers, driven away from John D. Rockefeller’s estate in Tarrytown by townspeople who met them near the station. Agitators were on their way to Croton Aqueduct to hold meeting which had been forbidden by the police.

July 4—Carl Hanson, Charles D. Berg and Arthur Caron blown to pieces while making bomb, believed to have been meant for Rockefellers. Six story tenement house, 1626 Lexington Avenue, near 103d Street, wrecked. Thirty families living there endangered; twenty persons injured; one woman killed. Italian flag torn down and red flag put in place at Garibaldi celebration in Rosebank, Staten Island. Attempt made to pull down American flag frustrated.

July 11—700 patrolmen with night sticks, also 50 mounted men, stationed in Union Square while Anarchists paid tribute to memory of Caron, Hanson and Berg; 9,000 in front of the speaker’s stand; red flag shown and inflammatory speeches made. No disorder, although meeting was almost broken up by militant peace advocates headed by Frank Urban.

September 19—Propaganda League I.W.W. held meeting in Union Square. One hundred and fifty protest against the arrest of J.M. Rangel, Charles Cline, and twelve other I.W.W. caught trying to take arms to Mexico. Deputy Sheriff had been killed by one of the band. Joseph J. Ettor, Elizabeth Gurley Flynn, Pietro Allegra, P. Korinsky and L. Nelson made fiery speeches.

October 13—Bomb explosions in St. Patrick’s Cathedral on north side of church interior, directly in front of St. Bernard’s Chapel. Small pieces of iron and screws, fragments of the bomb, marked one of the several Italian panels back of the Crucifix. Doors of three pews wrecked. Hole one foot in length and six inches in diameter made. Particles of the infernal machine chipped ceiling. Explosion occurred toward dusk.

October 13 midnight—St. Alphonsus Roman Catholic Church damaged by bomb which exploded near front entrance, West Broadway. Priests shaken out of beds. Brother Patrick cut by flying glass. Windows broken. Damage $1,000.

1915.

January 9—“Church worst enemy,” cry of I.W.W., headed by Joseph Ettor, as they broke up meeting called by Interchurch Unemployment Committee, Labor Lyceum, Fourteenth Street and Second Avenue.

January 16—Cardinal Newman, Father Bernard Vaughan and John Mitchel quoted as in favor of defying law and order in speech of Elizabeth Gurley Flynn at opening campaign of I.W.W. at 64 East Fourth Street.

February 4—Five I.W.W.’s fined $5 each for refusing to pay for food, referring bill to Mayor Mitchel.

February 16—I.W.W. induce 125 workers in shop run by Mayor Mitchel’s Committee on Unemployment to quit work, after demanding $2 a day in place of 50 cents for bandage rolling.
 

ATTACK INEXPLICABLE SAYS MGR. LAVELLE

Mgr. Lavelle, rector of St. Patrick’s Cathedral, had little to say about the attempt to wreck the edifice. “It is all inexplicable to me,” he said.

“I cannot explain these attempted outrages in the cathedral by any manner of reasoning, and they are all the more abominable and mysterious because the cathedral stands for the very lifeblood of the people.

“We must face facts as facts, however, and try to guard against such attacks, but that doesn’t mean that we can understand them.

“Sometimes it is said that the cathedral is attended by the wealthy and cultured of the city, but it is the church of all the people.”

Since the attempt to explode a bomb in the cathedral near the Fifth Avenue entrance last September, Mgr. Lavelle said, a careful watch had been kept to guard against attacks by dynamiters.
 

TERRORIST SYSTEM A MISFIT IN U.S.

Prof. Robinson Blames “Idea-Glimmerings” for Bomb Attempt.

CONDITIONS PROVE REDS IN ERROR

Pair That Planted Explosive Weak Criminals, Asserts One Analist [sic].

“Foreigners, with idea-glimmerings not worked out, with a terrorist philosophy that is a misfit in this country—that is how I would describe the planters of the bombs in St. Patrick’s Cathedral yesterday and anarchists of their type,” said John Harvey Robinson, professor of history in Columbia University and an authority on his historical philosophical subjects, in discussing last night, the arrest and frustrated plot of Abarno and Carbone.

“There is no justification for the existence of anarchists in the social conditions of this country,” he maintained. “It is hard to conceive the motives which impel such actions as theirs. One can understand the thoughts of a Russian nihilist who is not a criminal in the true sense, but who is working along the lines of a definite philosophy toward a definite end, or of the terrorists of Paris who engaged in the fight for the Commune in 1871.

“But things are different in this country. I can trace no analogy between conditions before the Commune of 1871 and the conditions in this country today which precede what the two Italian anarchists are said to have planned a commune of anarchy and riot in New York. There is no parallel of effect.

“The idea of a Commune being established here by men of the type of Abarno and Carbone is absurd. Even the most disreputable, the most-down-and-out of the hoboes and the unemployed in the city, would never follow such leaders to wholesale plunder and murder.

“The proof that conditions in this country do not justify the actions of the two men and their kind—that anarchy and anarchism are not natural outgrowths of existing society here is simple enough. Think what would happen if anarchists tied up the subway for a day! The whole city would band together for their suppression. Our civilization is too complex, too delicate, too sensitive, to stand such shocks without retaliation. There are not enough anarchists in the country to succeed in terrorizing New York for any length of time, for the simple reason that the community is constructed in such an orderly manner that no disturbance would be tolerated by it.

“The case of the Commune in Paris was different. The country and the city were already in a state of semi-anarchy. Police power and the more certain power of public opinion had vanished from Paris with the capture of the city, the death of her best citizens in the war with Germany and the starvation and suspension of business which followed. It can be said, in a general  way, that the struggle of the Commune in 1871, during which the Hotel de Ville, the Luxemburg and other public buildings were burned and thousands died before and behind the barricades of the anarchists, was the more or less natural result of conditions in the community.

“But that cannot be said of any attempted Commune in New York nor of the acts of the anarchists later. These can be attributed to misapplication of half-formed ideas and ideals, fitted, perhaps, to Russia or even to Italy, but not to conditions in the United States, which are totally different.”

Speaking more definitely of the make-up of the Bresci anarchists, A.T. Poffenburger, engaged in laboratory research and experimental work with the department of psychology at Columbia University, spoke of the terrorist plans revealed by yesterday’s arrests.

“There is no one positive type of mind that belongs to the ‘red,’” he said. “It is always possible to trace the causes of the criminal bent or his anarchistic instincts, if the facts of his birth and his life are known. It resolves itself into a matter of heredity and environment. I have not yet seen Carbone and Abarno, but I have known men of their stamp. Their mental attitude may be best expressed by “The world owes me a living!”

“It is not surprising that the two are so young. Tendencies which lead to crime usually show themselves between thirteen and twenty-five, or even earlier.”